- 2026-04-21 5mo Grimsby Town 2 at Cambridge Utd 1 Maldini Kacurri ENG-GRIM 90min yc
- 2025-09-13 1y Cambridge Utd 1 at Grimsby Town 1
- 2022-11-26 3y Grimsby Town 2 at Cambridge Utd 1 Otis Jan Mohammed Khan ENG-GRIM 90min 2g
- 2021-05-08 5y Grimsby Town 0 at Cambridge Utd 3 Wesley Hoolahan ENG-CAMU 90min 1g
- 2021-01-02 5y Cambridge Utd 2 at Grimsby Town 1 Adam John May ENG-CAMU 90min 1g
- 2019-10-23 6y Grimsby Town 0 at Cambridge Utd 0
- 2019-03-02 7y Cambridge Utd 2 at Grimsby Town 0 George William Taft ENG-CAMU 90min 1g
- 2018-11-03 7y Grimsby Town 0 at Cambridge Utd 1 Paul James Lewis ENG-CAMU 16min 1g
- 2018-02-17 8y Grimsby Town 1 at Cambridge Utd 3 Billy Henry Penna Waters ENG-CAMU 69min 1g
- 2017-10-28 8y Cambridge Utd 0 at Grimsby Town 0
- 2017-04-14 9y Cambridge Utd 1 at Grimsby Town 2 Christopher Clements ENG-GRIM 90min 1g
- 2016-10-15 10y Grimsby Town 1 at Cambridge Utd 0 James Trevor Berrett ENG-GRIM 90min 1g
- 2014-01-29 12y Grimsby Town 2 at Cambridge Utd 1 Lenell Nicholas John-Lewis ENG-GRIM 83min 1g
- 2013-10-09 13y Cambridge Utd 1 at Grimsby Town 0 Adam Cunnington ENG-CAMU 90min 1g
- 2013-03-16 13y Cambridge Utd 1 at Grimsby Town 0 Nick Pope ENG-CAMU 90min
- 2013-01-26 13y Grimsby Town 0 at Cambridge Utd 0
- 2012-01-11 14y Grimsby Town 1 at Cambridge Utd 0 Anthony Elding ENG-GRIM 88min 1g
- 2011-02-12 15y Cambridge Utd 1 at Grimsby Town 1
- 2010-11-10 15y Grimsby Town 1 at Cambridge Utd 1
- 2005-01-03 21y Cambridge Utd 0 at Grimsby Town 3
- 2004-09-25 22y Grimsby Town 2 at Cambridge Utd 0