- 2011-03-09 15y Birmingham City FC 1 at Everton 1
- 2010-10-02 16y Everton 2 at Birmingham City FC 0 Tim Cahill ENG-EVFJ 90min 1g
- 2010-03-13 16y Everton 2 at Birmingham City FC 2
- 2010-01-23 16y Birmingham City FC 2 at Everton 1 Barry Ferguson ENG-BIHV 90min 1g
- 2009-12-20 16y Birmingham City FC 1 at Everton 1
- 2008-04-12 18y Everton 1 at Birmingham City FC 1
- 2007-11-03 19y Birmingham City FC 1 at Everton 3 Lee Carsley ENG-EVFJ 90min 1g
- 2006-04-22 20y Birmingham City FC 0 at Everton 0
- 2005-10-29 21y Everton 1 at Birmingham City FC 0 Simon Davies ENG-EVFJ 90min 1g
- 2005-04-23 21y Birmingham City FC 1 at Everton 1
- 2004-11-13 21y Everton 1 at Birmingham City FC 0 Thomas Gravesen ENG-EVER 90min 1g
- 2004-02-11 22y Everton 0 at Birmingham City FC 3 Damien Johnson ENG-BIHV 90min 1g
- 2003-12-28 22y Birmingham City FC 0 at Everton 1 Wayne Mark Rooney ENG-EVFJ 44min 1g
- 2002-12-25 23y Everton 1 at Birmingham City FC 1
- 1986-01-18 40y Everton 2 at Birmingham City FC 0
- 1985-08-31 41y Birmingham City FC 1 at Everton 4
- 1983-09-24 43y Birmingham City FC 1 at Everton 1
- 1983-04-23 43y Everton 0 at Birmingham City FC 1
- 1982-12-04 43y Birmingham City FC 0 at Everton 0
- 1982-04-06 44y Everton 2 at Birmingham City FC 0
- 1981-05-02 45y Everton 1 at Birmingham City FC 1
- 1980-11-29 45y Birmingham City FC 1 at Everton 1
- 1979-04-28 47y Birmingham City FC 0 at Everton 1
- 1978-12-09 47y Everton 3 at Birmingham City FC 1
- 1977-12-17 48y Everton 0 at Birmingham City FC 0
- 1977-11-12 48y Birmingham City FC 1 at Everton 2
- 1977-05-14 49y Everton 1 at Birmingham City FC 1
- 1975-12-13 50y Birmingham City FC 2 at Everton 5
- 1975-08-23 51y Everton 1 at Birmingham City FC 0
- 1975-01-18 51y Everton 3 at Birmingham City FC 0
- 1974-11-30 51y Birmingham City FC 1 at Everton 4
- 1974-03-09 52y Birmingham City FC 1 at Everton 4
- 1973-10-27 53y Everton 2 at Birmingham City FC 0
- 1972-12-26 53y Birmingham City FC 1 at Everton 1
- 1972-09-23 54y Everton 1 at Birmingham City FC 2
- 1965-02-06 61y Birmingham City FC 1 at Everton 1
- 1964-09-26 62y Everton 5 at Birmingham City FC 3
- 1964-02-18 62y Birmingham City FC 0 at Everton 3
- 1963-10-05 63y Everton 2 at Birmingham City FC 0
- 1963-04-16 63y Everton 1 at Birmingham City FC 0
- 1963-04-15 63y Birmingham City FC 2 at Everton 2
- 1962-04-24 64y Everton 0 at Birmingham City FC 0
- 1962-04-20 64y Birmingham City FC 1 at Everton 4
- 1961-04-01 65y Birmingham City FC 0 at Everton 1
- 1960-12-10 65y Everton 4 at Birmingham City FC 2
- 1960-04-02 66y Everton 2 at Birmingham City FC 2
- 1959-11-14 66y Birmingham City FC 0 at Everton 4
- 1959-02-21 67y Everton 1 at Birmingham City FC 2
- 1958-10-04 68y Birmingham City FC 1 at Everton 3
- 1958-03-29 68y Everton 1 at Birmingham City FC 2