- 2024-01-21 2y West Ham United FC 2 at Sheffield Utd 2
- 2023-09-30 3y Sheffield Utd 0 at West Ham United FC 2 Tomáš Souček ENG-ESTH 90min 1g
- 2021-02-15 5y Sheffield Utd 0 at West Ham United FC 3 Issa Diop ENG-WEAL 90min 1g
- 2020-11-22 5y West Ham United FC 1 at Sheffield Utd 0 Sébastien Haller ENG-WEAL 90min 1g
- 2020-01-10 6y West Ham United FC 0 at Sheffield Utd 1 Oliver McBurnie WOR-SHEF 84min 1g
- 2019-10-26 6y Sheffield Utd 1 at West Ham United FC 1
- 2014-08-27 12y Sheffield Utd 1 at West Ham United FC 1 Mark Howard WOR-SHEF 90min
- 2007-04-14 19y West Ham United FC 0 at Sheffield Utd 3 Michael Tonge WOR-SHEF 90min 1g
- 2006-11-25 19y Sheffield Utd 0 at West Ham United FC 1 Hayden Ian Mullins ENG-WEAL 90min 1g yc
- 2005-02-13 21y West Ham United FC 1 at Sheffield Utd 1
- 2005-01-29 21y Sheffield Utd 1 at West Ham United FC 1
- 2005-01-03 21y Sheffield Utd 2 at West Ham United FC 0
- 1994-03-27 32y West Ham United FC 2 at Sheffield Utd 3
- 1994-01-02 32y Sheffield Utd 0 at West Ham United FC 0
- 1991-12-20 34y Sheffield Utd 1 at West Ham United FC 1
- 1991-08-19 35y West Ham United FC 1 at Sheffield Utd 1
- 1976-04-10 50y West Ham United FC 2 at Sheffield Utd 3
- 1975-09-20 51y Sheffield Utd 0 at West Ham United FC 2
- 1975-03-22 51y West Ham United FC 2 at Sheffield Utd 3
- 1974-09-07 52y Sheffield Utd 2 at West Ham United FC 1
- 1974-03-23 52y West Ham United FC 0 at Sheffield Utd 1
- 1973-11-10 52y Sheffield Utd 2 at West Ham United FC 2
- 1973-03-10 53y West Ham United FC 0 at Sheffield Utd 0
- 1972-10-14 54y Sheffield Utd 1 at West Ham United FC 3
- 1972-02-29 54y West Ham United FC 0 at Sheffield Utd 3
- 1971-11-06 54y Sheffield Utd 2 at West Ham United FC 1
- 1968-04-27 58y West Ham United FC 2 at Sheffield Utd 1
- 1967-04-04 59y Sheffield Utd 2 at West Ham United FC 0
- 1966-02-19 60y Sheffield Utd 0 at West Ham United FC 4
- 1965-02-06 61y West Ham United FC 1 at Sheffield Utd 2
- 1964-09-26 62y Sheffield Utd 1 at West Ham United FC 3
- 1964-01-11 62y West Ham United FC 1 at Sheffield Utd 2
- 1963-09-07 63y Sheffield Utd 3 at West Ham United FC 2
- 1963-02-16 63y West Ham United FC 2 at Sheffield Utd 0
- 1962-09-29 64y Sheffield Utd 1 at West Ham United FC 1
- 1962-02-10 64y Sheffield Utd 2 at West Ham United FC 1
- 1931-09-21 95y Sheffield Utd 2 at West Ham United FC 1
- 1931-03-07 95y West Ham United FC 2 at Sheffield Utd 1
- 1930-04-18 96y Sheffield Utd 0 at West Ham United FC 1
- 1930-01-01 96y West Ham United FC 2 at Sheffield Utd 4
- 1928-12-29 97y West Ham United FC 3 at Sheffield Utd 3
- 1927-03-12 99y Sheffield Utd 0 at West Ham United FC 3
- 1926-10-23 100y West Ham United FC 2 at Sheffield Utd 0
- 1926-02-27 100y West Ham United FC 1 at Sheffield Utd 1
- 1925-10-17 101y Sheffield Utd 3 at West Ham United FC 1
- 1925-04-14 101y Sheffield Utd 2 at West Ham United FC 6
- 1924-09-22 102y West Ham United FC 1 at Sheffield Utd 1
- 1924-04-21 102y Sheffield Utd 2 at West Ham United FC 2
- 1924-01-01 102y West Ham United FC 2 at Sheffield Utd 0