- 2025-01-04 1y Leicester City 1 at Aston Villa 2 Leon Bailey Butler ENG-ASTO 90min 1g
- 2024-08-31 2y Aston Villa 2 at Leicester City 1 Lucas Digne ENG-ASTO 90min 1a
- 2023-04-04 3y Aston Villa 2 at Leicester City 1 Ollie Watkins ENG-ASTO 90min 1g
- 2023-02-04 3y Leicester City 4 at Aston Villa 2 Kelechi Promise Iheanacho ENG-LEDG 67min 1g 2a
- 2022-04-23 4y Aston Villa 0 at Leicester City 0
- 2021-12-05 4y Leicester City 1 at Aston Villa 2 Ezri Konsa Ngoyo ENG-ASPV 90min 2g
- 2021-02-21 5y Leicester City 2 at Aston Villa 1 Harvey Lewis Barnes ENG-LEDG 90min 1g
- 2020-10-18 6y Aston Villa 1 at Leicester City 0 Ross Barkley ENG-ASPV 90min 1g
- 2020-03-09 6y Aston Villa 0 at Leicester City 4 Harvey Lewis Barnes ENG-LEDG 90min 2g
- 2019-12-08 6y Leicester City 4 at Aston Villa 1 Jamie Vardy ENG-LEDG 90min 2g
- 2016-01-16 10y Leicester City 1 at Aston Villa 1
- 2015-09-13 11y Aston Villa 2 at Leicester City 3 Ritchie Ria Alfons De Laet ENG-LEDG 90min 1g
- 2015-02-15 11y Leicester City 1 at Aston Villa 2 Leandro Jones Johan Bacuna ENG-ASPV 77min 1g
- 2015-01-10 11y Aston Villa 0 at Leicester City 1 Paul Konchesky ENG-LEDG 90min 1g
- 2014-12-07 11y Leicester City 1 at Aston Villa 2 Ciaran Clark ENG-ASPV 90min 1g
- 2007-09-27 19y Leicester City 1 at Aston Villa 0
- 2006-10-24 20y Aston Villa 3 at Leicester City 2
- 2004-01-31 22y Aston Villa 5 at Leicester City 0 Peter Crouch ENG-ASPV 90min 2g
- 2003-08-30 23y Leicester City 1 at Aston Villa 3 Juan Pablo Ángel Arango ENG-ASPV 90min 2g
- 2002-04-19 24y Aston Villa 2 at Leicester City 2
- 2001-11-30 24y Leicester City 2 at Aston Villa 0
- 2001-04-03 25y Leicester City 1 at Aston Villa 2
- 2000-08-18 26y Aston Villa 0 at Leicester City 0
- 1999-09-24 27y Aston Villa 1 at Leicester City 3
- 1999-04-05 27y Aston Villa 2 at Leicester City 2
- 1998-10-23 28y Leicester City 1 at Aston Villa 1
- 1998-01-09 28y Leicester City 1 at Aston Villa 1
- 1997-08-08 29y Aston Villa 0 at Leicester City 1
- 1997-03-04 29y Aston Villa 0 at Leicester City 1
- 1996-11-15 29y Leicester City 3 at Aston Villa 1
- 1995-02-21 31y Leicester City 4 at Aston Villa 4
- 1987-04-11 39y Aston Villa 1 at Leicester City 1
- 1986-11-01 39y Leicester City 0 at Aston Villa 2
- 1986-03-31 40y Leicester City 0 at Aston Villa 1
- 1985-12-26 40y Aston Villa 1 at Leicester City 3
- 1985-03-02 41y Leicester City 1 at Aston Villa 0
- 1984-10-27 42y Aston Villa 0 at Leicester City 5
- 1984-04-14 42y Aston Villa 0 at Leicester City 2
- 1983-11-19 42y Leicester City 1 at Aston Villa 3
- 1981-04-04 45y Aston Villa 4 at Leicester City 2
- 1980-11-01 45y Leicester City 0 at Aston Villa 2
- 1978-03-04 48y Leicester City 0 at Aston Villa 0
- 1976-03-20 50y Aston Villa 2 at Leicester City 2
- 1975-11-29 50y Leicester City 1 at Aston Villa 1
- 1967-02-04 59y Leicester City 1 at Aston Villa 0
- 1966-02-05 60y Aston Villa 1 at Leicester City 2
- 1965-04-20 61y Leicester City 0 at Aston Villa 1
- 1965-04-19 61y Aston Villa 1 at Leicester City 1
- 1964-04-18 62y Leicester City 3 at Aston Villa 1
- 1963-12-07 62y Aston Villa 0 at Leicester City 0