- 2021-03-14 5y Sheffield Utd 0 at Leicester City 5 Kelechi Promise Iheanacho ENG-LEDG 90min 3g
- 2020-12-06 5y Leicester City 2 at Sheffield Utd 1 Ayoze Pérez Gutiérrez ENG-LEDG 69min 1g
- 2020-07-16 6y Sheffield Utd 0 at Leicester City 2 Ayoze Pérez Gutiérrez ENG-LEDG 71min 1g
- 2018-02-17 8y Sheffield Utd 0 at Leicester City 1 Jamie Vardy ENG-LEDG 84min 1g
- 2017-08-23 9y Leicester City 4 at Sheffield Utd 1 Demarai Gray ENG-LEDG 90min 1g
- 2011-02-02 15y Leicester City 1 at Sheffield Utd 0 Andrew Philip King ENG-LEDG 90min 1g
- 2010-11-11 15y Sheffield Utd 2 at Leicester City 2
- 2009-12-27 16y Sheffield Utd 1 at Leicester City 2 Michael Morrison ENG-LEDG 90min 1g
- 2008-04-05 18y Leicester City 0 at Sheffield Utd 3
- 2007-10-24 18y Sheffield Utd 1 at Leicester City 0
- 2004-12-28 21y Leicester City 0 at Sheffield Utd 2
- 2003-04-21 23y Leicester City 1 at Sheffield Utd 2
- 2002-12-07 23y Sheffield Utd 0 at Leicester City 0
- 1996-03-30 30y Sheffield Utd 2 at Leicester City 0
- 1995-10-21 31y Leicester City 3 at Sheffield Utd 1
- 1976-02-21 50y Sheffield Utd 1 at Leicester City 1
- 1975-11-15 50y Leicester City 2 at Sheffield Utd 1
- 1975-04-26 51y Leicester City 0 at Sheffield Utd 4
- 1974-10-19 52y Sheffield Utd 0 at Leicester City 3
- 1974-02-23 52y Sheffield Utd 1 at Leicester City 1
- 1973-10-06 53y Leicester City 1 at Sheffield Utd 1
- 1973-02-24 53y Sheffield Utd 0 at Leicester City 0
- 1972-12-16 53y Leicester City 0 at Sheffield Utd 2
- 1972-01-01 54y Leicester City 1 at Sheffield Utd 1
- 1971-09-18 55y Sheffield Utd 1 at Leicester City 0
- 1968-03-02 58y Sheffield Utd 1 at Leicester City 3
- 1967-04-22 59y Sheffield Utd 2 at Leicester City 2
- 1966-11-26 59y Leicester City 1 at Sheffield Utd 0
- 1966-03-19 60y Sheffield Utd 0 at Leicester City 1
- 1965-03-26 61y Leicester City 2 at Sheffield Utd 0
- 1964-11-14 61y Sheffield Utd 2 at Leicester City 0
- 1964-03-21 62y Leicester City 1 at Sheffield Utd 0
- 1963-11-09 62y Sheffield Utd 1 at Leicester City 0
- 1963-03-26 63y Leicester City 0 at Sheffield Utd 0
- 1962-10-27 63y Sheffield Utd 1 at Leicester City 3
- 1962-02-24 64y Leicester City 1 at Sheffield Utd 3
- 1954-12-27 71y Sheffield Utd 1 at Leicester City 0
- 1933-09-04 93y Leicester City 1 at Sheffield Utd 2
- 1933-08-28 93y Sheffield Utd 0 at Leicester City 4
- 1932-12-31 93y Leicester City 2 at Sheffield Utd 5
- 1932-08-27 94y Sheffield Utd 1 at Leicester City 1
- 1932-03-19 94y Leicester City 2 at Sheffield Utd 2
- 1931-11-07 94y Sheffield Utd 3 at Leicester City 4
- 1930-01-04 96y Leicester City 1 at Sheffield Utd 7
- 1929-09-07 97y Sheffield Utd 3 at Leicester City 3
- 1929-02-23 97y Leicester City 4 at Sheffield Utd 1
- 1928-10-13 98y Sheffield Utd 1 at Leicester City 3
- 1927-03-19 99y Leicester City 3 at Sheffield Utd 0
- 1926-10-30 99y Sheffield Utd 2 at Leicester City 2
- 1925-12-26 100y Sheffield Utd 2 at Leicester City 2