- 2024-02-03 2y Aston Villa 5 at Sheffield Utd 0 Ollie Watkins ENG-ASTO 90min
- 2023-12-22 2y Sheffield Utd 1 at Aston Villa 1
- 2021-03-03 5y Aston Villa 0 at Sheffield Utd 1 George Baldock WOR-SHEF 90min 1a
- 2020-09-21 6y Sheffield Utd 0 at Aston Villa 1 Ezri Konsa Ngoyo ENG-ASPV 90min 1g
- 2020-06-17 6y Sheffield Utd 0 at Aston Villa 0
- 2019-12-14 6y Aston Villa 0 at Sheffield Utd 2 John Fleck WOR-SHEF 90min 2g yc
- 2019-02-09 7y Sheffield Utd 3 at Aston Villa 3
- 2018-01-31 8y Aston Villa 1 at Sheffield Utd 0 Robert Snodgrass ENG-ASPV 90min 1g
- 2017-12-24 8y Sheffield Utd 2 at Aston Villa 2
- 2014-01-04 12y Sheffield Utd 2 at Aston Villa 1 James Murphy WOR-SHEF 90min 1g
- 2011-01-08 15y Aston Villa 3 at Sheffield Utd 1 Kyle Walker ENG-ASPV 90min 1g
- 2007-05-05 19y Sheffield Utd 0 at Aston Villa 3 Ashley Young ENG-ASPV 90min 1g
- 2006-12-11 19y Aston Villa 2 at Sheffield Utd 2
- 2005-01-08 21y Aston Villa 1 at Sheffield Utd 3
- 1994-04-15 32y Aston Villa 2 at Sheffield Utd 1
- 1993-11-19 32y Sheffield Utd 0 at Aston Villa 1
- 1993-01-26 33y Sheffield Utd 1 at Aston Villa 3
- 1992-08-28 34y Aston Villa 2 at Sheffield Utd 0
- 1992-03-30 34y Sheffield Utd 1 at Aston Villa 1
- 1991-12-13 34y Aston Villa 0 at Sheffield Utd 2
- 1976-02-14 50y Aston Villa 1 at Sheffield Utd 2
- 1975-11-08 50y Sheffield Utd 1 at Aston Villa 5
- 1967-03-18 59y Aston Villa 3 at Sheffield Utd 3
- 1966-01-29 60y Sheffield Utd 2 at Aston Villa 0
- 1965-04-17 61y Sheffield Utd 1 at Aston Villa 2
- 1964-12-05 61y Aston Villa 2 at Sheffield Utd 4
- 1964-02-08 62y Aston Villa 1 at Sheffield Utd 1
- 1963-09-28 63y Sheffield Utd 1 at Aston Villa 0
- 1963-05-01 63y Aston Villa 1 at Sheffield Utd 2
- 1962-09-15 64y Sheffield Utd 2 at Aston Villa 1
- 1962-01-13 64y Sheffield Utd 0 at Aston Villa 0
- 1956-04-14 70y Sheffield Utd 2 at Aston Villa 3
- 1955-12-03 70y Aston Villa 2 at Sheffield Utd 2
- 1955-04-16 71y Sheffield Utd 1 at Aston Villa 3
- 1954-04-26 72y Aston Villa 1 at Sheffield Utd 2
- 1949-02-26 77y Aston Villa 1 at Sheffield Utd 0
- 1948-10-02 78y Sheffield Utd 3 at Aston Villa 4
- 1948-03-06 78y Aston Villa 1 at Sheffield Utd 3
- 1947-10-18 79y Sheffield Utd 0 at Aston Villa 2
- 1947-04-05 79y Aston Villa 2 at Sheffield Utd 1
- 1946-11-30 79y Sheffield Utd 3 at Aston Villa 2
- 1934-04-02 92y Sheffield Utd 0 at Aston Villa 3
- 1934-01-01 92y Aston Villa 3 at Sheffield Utd 3
- 1933-04-24 93y Aston Villa 0 at Sheffield Utd 1
- 1932-10-15 94y Sheffield Utd 0 at Aston Villa 3
- 1932-04-23 94y Sheffield Utd 0 at Aston Villa 5
- 1931-12-12 94y Aston Villa 4 at Sheffield Utd 5
- 1931-04-11 95y Sheffield Utd 0 at Aston Villa 4
- 1930-12-06 95y Aston Villa 4 at Sheffield Utd 3
- 1930-04-19 96y Aston Villa 3 at Sheffield Utd 3