- 2025-10-11 1y Indy Eleven 1 at Pittsburgh 2 Sean Suber USA-PITT 1g
- 2025-06-14 1y Pittsburgh 0 at Indy Eleven 1 Eric Dick USA-PITT 90min
- 2025-02-12 1y Pittsburgh 2 at Indy Eleven 1
- 2024-08-31 2y Pittsburgh 1 at Indy Eleven 1
- 2024-06-01 2y Indy Eleven 2 at Pittsburgh 1 Sebastián Ignacio Guenzatti Varela USA-INDY 61min 1g
- 2023-07-26 3y Indy Eleven 3 at Pittsburgh 1 Tim Trilk USA-INLY 90min
- 2023-04-29 3y Pittsburgh 1 at Indy Eleven 1
- 2022-08-07 4y Pittsburgh 2 at Indy Eleven 0 Russell Cicerone USA-PIVE 59min 2g
- 2022-07-06 4y Indy Eleven 0 at Pittsburgh 1 Albert Dikwa Lega USA-PIVE 30min 1g
- 2021-06-15 5y Pittsburgh 1 at Indy Eleven 0 Thomas Williamson USA-PIVE 64min 1g yc
- 2019-09-29 7y Indy Eleven 0 at Pittsburgh 3 Kenardo Forbes USA-PIVE 90min 2g
- 2019-06-02 7y Pittsburgh 1 at Indy Eleven 2 Tyler Geoffrey Pasher USA-INLY 90min 1g
- 2019-05-30 7y Indy Eleven 0 at Pittsburgh 1 Kenardo Forbes USA-PIVE 9min 1g
- 2018-09-23 8y Indy Eleven 2 at Pittsburgh 3 Joseph Greenspan USA-PIVE 90min 1g
- 2018-08-30 8y Pittsburgh 2 at Indy Eleven 2
- 2018-05-12 8y Indy Eleven 0 at Pittsburgh 0