- 2025-11-23 10mo New York City 1 at Philadelphia Union 0
- 2025-10-04 1y New York City 0 at Philadelphia Union 1
- 2025-04-12 1y Philadelphia Union 0 at New York City 1 Adrián Alonso Martínez Batista USA-NEWT 90min 1g
- 2024-01-27 2y Philadelphia Union 3 at New York City 1
- 2023-07-15 3y New York City 1 at Philadelphia Union 2 José Andrés Martínez Torres USA-PHTF 90min 1g
- 2023-05-27 3y Philadelphia Union 3 at New York City 1 Julián Simón Carranza USA-PHTF 86min 2g
- 2022-10-30 3y New York City 1 at Philadelphia Union 3 Dániel Gazdag USA-PHTF 90min 1g
- 2022-06-26 4y New York City 1 at Philadelphia Union 2 Cory Burke USA-PHTF 24min 1g
- 2022-03-19 4y Philadelphia Union 2 at New York City 0 Alejandro Bedoya USA-PHTF 90min 1g
- 2021-12-05 4y New York City 2 at Philadelphia Union 1 Alexander Martín Marquinho Callens Asín USA-NEPF 90min 1g
- 2021-11-07 4y Philadelphia Union 1 at New York City 1
- 2021-08-18 5y New York City 0 at Philadelphia Union 1 Alejandro Bedoya USA-PHTF 89min 1g
- 2021-05-01 5y New York City 2 at Philadelphia Union 0 Sean Johnson USA-NEPF 90min
- 2020-07-09 6y Philadelphia Union 1 at New York City 0 Alejandro Bedoya USA-PHTF 84min 1g
- 2019-10-06 7y New York City 2 at Philadelphia Union 1 Valentín Mariano José Castellanos Giménez USA-NEPF 90min 2a
- 2019-06-29 7y Philadelphia Union 2 at New York City 4 Maximiliano Nicol Moralez USA-NEPF 90min 2g
- 2018-10-31 7y Philadelphia Union 1 at New York City 3 Maximiliano Nicol Moralez USA-DAWM 90min 1g 2a
- 2018-10-28 7y Philadelphia Union 1 at New York City 3 Maximiliano Nicol Moralez USA-NEPF 68min
- 2018-08-18 8y New York City 0 at Philadelphia Union 2 Cory Burke USA-PHTF 90min 1g
- 2017-06-03 9y Philadelphia Union 1 at New York City 2 Alexander Martín Marquinho Callens Asín USA-NEPF 90min 1g
- 2017-04-14 9y New York City 2 at Philadelphia Union 0 David Villa Sánchez USA-NEPF 90min 1g
- 2016-06-18 10y Philadelphia Union 2 at New York City 3 Frédéric Brillant USA-NEPF 90min 1g
- 2016-04-23 10y New York City 0 at Philadelphia Union 2 Charles Kwabena Sapong USA-PHTF 90min 1g
- 2015-06-06 11y New York City 2 at Philadelphia Union 1 Thomas Liam McNamara USA-NEPF 90min 1g
- 2015-04-16 11y Philadelphia Union 1 at New York City 1
- 2015-04-11 11y New York City 1 at Philadelphia Union 2 Vincent Nogueira USA-PHTF 90min 1g