- 2026-10-10 1w Columbus Crew 2 at Orlando City 3 Antoine Griezmann USA-ORLA 90min 1g 1a
- 2025-10-04 1y Columbus Crew 1 at Orlando City 1
- 2025-07-25 1y Orlando City 3 at Columbus Crew 1
- 2025-07-25 1y Columbus Crew 1 at Orlando City 3 Martín Exequiel Ojeda USA-ORLA 90min 1g
- 2023-09-16 3y Columbus Crew 3 at Orlando City 4 Martín Exequiel Ojeda USA-ORHN 90min 1g 1a
- 2023-05-13 3y Orlando City 2 at Columbus Crew 2
- 2022-10-09 4y Columbus Crew 1 at Orlando City 2 Kyle Smith USA-ORHN 90min yc
- 2022-04-16 4y Orlando City 2 at Columbus Crew 0 Ercan Kara USA-ORHN 70min 1g
- 2021-10-27 4y Orlando City 2 at Columbus Crew 3 Lucas Manuel Zelarayán USA-COKE 75min 1g
- 2021-09-04 5y Columbus Crew 2 at Orlando City 3 Daryl Dike USA-ORHN 77min 1g
- 2020-11-04 5y Columbus Crew 1 at Orlando City 2 Christopher Mueller USA-ORHN 59min 1g
- 2019-07-13 7y Columbus Crew 0 at Orlando City 1 Benji Michel USA-ORHN 90min 1g
- 2019-06-29 7y Orlando City 2 at Columbus Crew 0 Tesho Akindele USA-ORHN 87min 1g
- 2018-10-21 8y Columbus Crew 1 at Orlando City 2 Sacha Klještan USA-ORHN 90min 1g
- 2018-07-21 8y Orlando City 2 at Columbus Crew 3 Gyasi Zardes USA-COKE 90min 2g
- 2017-10-15 9y Columbus Crew 1 at Orlando City 0 Ola Williams Kamara USA-COKE 90min 1g
- 2017-08-19 9y Columbus Crew 1 at Orlando City 1
- 2017-04-01 9y Orlando City 0 at Columbus Crew 2 Justin Meram USA-COKE 90min 2g yc
- 2016-09-17 10y Columbus Crew 4 at Orlando City 1 Ethan Christopher Finlay USA-COKE 90min 1g
- 2016-07-23 10y Orlando City 2 at Columbus Crew 2
- 2015-08-01 11y Columbus Crew 2 at Orlando City 5 Aurélien Collin USA-ORHN 90min 2g
- 2015-07-01 11y Columbus Crew 0 at Orlando City 2 Ricardo Izecson dos Santos Leite USA-ORHN 86min 1g
- 2015-05-30 11y Columbus Crew 2 at Orlando City 2
- 2015-04-18 11y Orlando City 0 at Columbus Crew 3 Federico Fernando Higuaín USA-COKE 90min 1g
- 2014-02-27 12y Columbus Crew 4 at Orlando City 4