- 2025-09-20 1y Toronto FC 1 at Columbus Crew 1
- 2025-09-20 1y Columbus Crew 1 at Toronto FC 1
- 2025-08-16 1y Columbus Crew 1 at Toronto FC 1
- 2023-08-26 3y Toronto FC 0 at Columbus Crew 2 Patrick Schulte USA-COKE 90min 1a
- 2023-03-11 3y Columbus Crew 1 at Toronto FC 1
- 2022-03-12 4y Toronto FC 1 at Columbus Crew 2 Derrick Etienne USA-COKE 90min 1g
- 2021-05-29 5y Toronto FC 1 at Columbus Crew 2 Eloy Victor Room USA-COKE 90min
- 2021-05-12 5y Columbus Crew 0 at Toronto FC 2 Michael Bradley CAN-TORH 90min 1g
- 2020-09-27 6y Columbus Crew 1 at Toronto FC 3 Richie Laryea CAN-TORH 90min 1g
- 2019-10-06 7y Columbus Crew 0 at Toronto FC 1 Michael Bradley CAN-TORH 90min yc
- 2019-08-17 7y Toronto FC 2 at Columbus Crew 2
- 2018-06-02 8y Toronto FC 3 at Columbus Crew 3
- 2018-03-03 8y Columbus Crew 2 at Toronto FC 0 Gyasi Zardes USA-COKE 90min 1g
- 2017-11-29 8y Columbus Crew 0 at Toronto FC 1 Jozy Altidore CAN-TORH 68min 1g
- 2017-11-21 8y Toronto FC 0 at Columbus Crew 0
- 2017-05-26 9y Columbus Crew 0 at Toronto FC 5 Víctor Vázquez Solsona CAN-TORH 68min 2g
- 2017-05-10 9y Toronto FC 2 at Columbus Crew 1 Tosaint Ricketts CAN-TORH 50min 2g
- 2017-04-15 9y Toronto FC 1 at Columbus Crew 2 Ola Williams Kamara USA-COKE 90min 1g
- 2016-07-31 10y Columbus Crew 0 at Toronto FC 3 Sebastian Giovinco CAN-TORH 90min 1g
- 2016-07-13 10y Toronto FC 1 at Columbus Crew 1
- 2016-05-21 10y Columbus Crew 0 at Toronto FC 0
- 2015-10-17 11y Columbus Crew 2 at Toronto FC 0 Ethan Christopher Finlay USA-COKE 90min 1g
- 2015-07-25 11y Toronto FC 3 at Columbus Crew 3
- 2015-03-14 11y Toronto FC 0 at Columbus Crew 2 Kaiansu Kei Kamara USA-COKE 90min 1g
- 2014-08-09 12y Toronto FC 3 at Columbus Crew 2 Luke Moore CAN-TORH 90min 1g
- 2014-05-31 12y Columbus Crew 2 at Toronto FC 3 Jermain Colin Defoe CAN-TORH 90min 2g
- 2014-04-05 12y Toronto FC 2 at Columbus Crew 0 Michael Bradley CAN-TORH 73min 1g
- 2014-02-20 12y Toronto FC 1 at Columbus Crew 3
- 2013-08-17 13y Toronto FC 0 at Columbus Crew 2 Federico Fernando Higuaín USA-COKE 90min 2g
- 2013-07-27 13y Columbus Crew 1 at Toronto FC 2 Jonathan Osorio CAN-TORH 90min 1g yc
- 2013-05-18 13y Columbus Crew 1 at Toronto FC 0 Dominic Oduro USA-COKE 85min 1g
- 2012-10-28 13y Toronto FC 1 at Columbus Crew 2 Federico Fernando Higuaín USA-COKE 90min 2g
- 2012-08-22 14y Toronto FC 1 at Columbus Crew 2 Eddie Gaven USA-COKE 90min 1g
- 2012-03-31 14y Columbus Crew 1 at Toronto FC 0 Bernardo Añor Acosta USA-COKE 85min 1g
- 2011-09-10 15y Toronto FC 4 at Columbus Crew 2 Julián de Guzmán CAN-TORH 90min 1g
- 2011-04-23 15y Columbus Crew 1 at Toronto FC 1
- 2010-10-16 16y Columbus Crew 2 at Toronto FC 2
- 2010-03-27 16y Toronto FC 0 at Columbus Crew 2 Guillermo Barros Schelotto USA-COKE 90min 1g
- 2009-07-25 17y Toronto FC 2 at Columbus Crew 3 Eddie Gaven USA-COKE 90min 1g
- 2009-05-02 17y Columbus Crew 1 at Toronto FC 1
- 2009-03-28 17y Toronto FC 1 at Columbus Crew 1
- 2008-09-13 18y Columbus Crew 1 at Toronto FC 1
- 2008-05-17 18y Columbus Crew 0 at Toronto FC 0
- 2008-03-29 18y Toronto FC 0 at Columbus Crew 2 Adam Moffat USA-COKE 90min 1g
- 2007-09-22 19y Columbus Crew 2 at Toronto FC 1 Jason Garey USA-COKE 72min 1g
- 2007-07-22 19y Toronto FC 0 at Columbus Crew 2 Guillermo Barros Schelotto USA-COKE 73min 2g
- 2007-05-25 19y Toronto FC 2 at Columbus Crew 2