- 2025-06-25 1y Toronto FC 1 at New York Red Bulls 1
- 2025-06-25 1y New York Red Bulls 1 at Toronto FC 1
- 2025-03-22 1y Toronto FC 1 at New York Red Bulls 2 Emil Peter Forsberg USA-NEWY 90min 2g
- 2023-10-07 3y Toronto FC 0 at New York Red Bulls 3 Lucas Lima Linhares USA-NENV 90min 2g
- 2023-05-17 3y New York Red Bulls 0 at Toronto FC 0
- 2022-06-18 4y Toronto FC 0 at New York Red Bulls 2 Lewis Morgan USA-NENV 90min 1g
- 2022-03-05 4y New York Red Bulls 4 at Toronto FC 1 Lewis Morgan USA-NENV 90min 3g
- 2021-07-21 5y New York Red Bulls 1 at Toronto FC 1
- 2021-05-08 5y Toronto FC 0 at New York Red Bulls 2 Carlos Miguel Coronel USA-NENV 90min
- 2020-11-08 5y Toronto FC 1 at New York Red Bulls 2 Kyle Duncan USA-NENV 90min 1a
- 2020-10-14 6y New York Red Bulls 1 at Toronto FC 1
- 2019-08-03 7y Toronto FC 0 at New York Red Bulls 2 Kemar Michael Lawrence USA-NENV 90min 1g
- 2019-07-17 7y New York Red Bulls 1 at Toronto FC 3 Jozy Altidore CAN-TORH 90min 1g
- 2018-09-22 8y Toronto FC 0 at New York Red Bulls 2 Alejandro Sebastián Romero Gamarra USA-NENV 82min 1g
- 2018-07-01 8y New York Red Bulls 1 at Toronto FC 0 Kemar Michael Lawrence USA-NENV 90min 1g
- 2017-11-05 8y New York Red Bulls 1 at Toronto FC 0 Sacha Klještan USA-NENV 90min yc
- 2017-10-30 8y Toronto FC 2 at New York Red Bulls 1 Víctor Vázquez Solsona CAN-TORH 65min 1g
- 2017-09-30 9y New York Red Bulls 2 at Toronto FC 4 Justin Morrow CAN-TORH 90min 3g
- 2017-05-19 9y Toronto FC 1 at New York Red Bulls 1
- 2016-09-18 10y New York Red Bulls 3 at Toronto FC 3
- 2016-05-28 10y Toronto FC 0 at New York Red Bulls 3 Bradley Wright-Phillips USA-NENV 83min 3g
- 2016-03-06 10y Toronto FC 2 at New York Red Bulls 0 Sebastian Giovinco CAN-TORH 90min 1g yc
- 2015-10-14 11y New York Red Bulls 1 at Toronto FC 2 Hérculez Gómez Hurtado CAN-TORH 71min (sub in 19) 1g
- 2015-08-15 11y Toronto FC 0 at New York Red Bulls 3 Anthony Wallace USA-NENV 90min 1g
- 2014-10-11 12y Toronto FC 1 at New York Red Bulls 3 Bradley Wright-Phillips USA-NENV 88min 1g
- 2014-06-27 12y Toronto FC 2 at New York Red Bulls 2
- 2014-05-17 12y New York Red Bulls 0 at Toronto FC 2 Jermain Colin Defoe CAN-TORH 90min 1g yc
- 2013-09-14 13y Toronto FC 0 at New York Red Bulls 2 Thierry Henry USA-NENV 90min 1g
- 2013-07-20 13y New York Red Bulls 0 at Toronto FC 0
- 2013-04-27 13y New York Red Bulls 2 at Toronto FC 1 Tim Cahill USA-NENV 90min 2g
- 2012-09-29 14y Toronto FC 1 at New York Red Bulls 4 Thierry Henry USA-NENV 90min 1g
- 2012-06-30 14y New York Red Bulls 1 at Toronto FC 1
- 2011-10-01 15y New York Red Bulls 1 at Toronto FC 1
- 2011-07-06 15y Toronto FC 0 at New York Red Bulls 5 Joel Lindpere USA-NENV 90min 1g
- 2010-08-21 16y New York Red Bulls 4 at Toronto FC 1 Juan Pablo Ángel Arango USA-NENV 90min 1g
- 2010-08-11 16y Toronto FC 0 at New York Red Bulls 1 Joel Lindpere USA-NENV 90min 1g
- 2009-10-24 16y Toronto FC 0 at New York Red Bulls 5 Macoumba Kandji USA-COKE 90min 2g 1a
- 2009-06-24 17y New York Red Bulls 0 at Toronto FC 2 Pablo Ernesto Vitti CAN-TORH 76min 1g
- 2009-06-13 17y New York Red Bulls 1 at Toronto FC 2 Sam Cronin CAN-TORH 90min 1g
- 2008-10-04 18y Toronto FC 3 at New York Red Bulls 1 Chad Barrett CAN-TORH 80min 2g yc
- 2008-08-17 18y Toronto FC 0 at New York Red Bulls 2 Michael Magee USA-NENV 90min 1g
- 2008-05-01 18y New York Red Bulls 1 at Toronto FC 1
- 2007-10-04 19y New York Red Bulls 1 at Toronto FC 2 Maurice Edu CAN-TORH 90min 1g yc
- 2007-08-12 19y Toronto FC 0 at New York Red Bulls 3 Juan Pablo Ángel Arango USA-NENV 90min 1g
- 2007-06-05 19y New York Red Bulls 2 at Toronto FC 1 Juan Pablo Ángel Arango USA-NENV 90min 2g