- 2025-05-10 1y DC United 0 at Toronto FC 2 Lorenzo Insigne CAN-TORO 81min 1g
- 2025-02-22 1y Toronto FC 2 at DC United 2
- 2023-05-27 3y DC United 1 at Toronto FC 2 Lorenzo Insigne CAN-TORH 90min 2a
- 2023-02-25 3y Toronto FC 2 at DC United 3 Mateusz Andrzej Klich USA-DCJH 90min 1g
- 2022-05-21 4y Toronto FC 2 at DC United 2
- 2022-03-19 4y DC United 1 at Toronto FC 2 Alejandro Pozuelo Melero CAN-TORH 90min 1g yc
- 2021-11-07 4y DC United 3 at Toronto FC 1 Bilal Abdul Hamid USA-DCJH 90min
- 2021-07-03 5y Toronto FC 1 at DC United 7 Paul Joseph Arriola Hendricks USA-DCJH 90min 1g
- 2020-09-19 6y Toronto FC 2 at DC United 2
- 2020-07-13 6y DC United 2 at Toronto FC 2
- 2019-10-19 7y DC United 1 at Toronto FC 5 Alejandro Pozuelo Melero CAN-TORH 90min 1a
- 2019-06-29 7y Toronto FC 1 at DC United 1
- 2019-05-15 7y DC United 0 at Toronto FC 0
- 2018-10-17 8y Toronto FC 0 at DC United 1 Wayne Mark Rooney USA-DCJH 90min 1g
- 2018-06-13 8y DC United 4 at Toronto FC 4
- 2017-08-05 9y Toronto FC 1 at DC United 1
- 2017-06-17 9y DC United 0 at Toronto FC 2 Jozy Altidore CAN-TORH 78min 1g yc
- 2016-10-01 10y DC United 2 at Toronto FC 1 Lamar Neagle USA-DCJH 90min 2g
- 2016-07-23 10y DC United 1 at Toronto FC 4 Sebastian Giovinco CAN-TORH 90min 3g
- 2016-04-16 10y Toronto FC 1 at DC United 0 Sebastian Giovinco CAN-TORH 90min 1g
- 2015-06-27 11y DC United 0 at Toronto FC 0
- 2015-06-06 11y Toronto FC 2 at DC United 1 Sebastian Giovinco CAN-TORH 90min 2g
- 2014-07-30 12y Toronto FC 0 at DC United 3 Chris Rolfe USA-DCJH 74min 1g
- 2014-07-05 12y DC United 2 at Toronto FC 1 Perry Kitchen USA-DCJH 90min 1g
- 2014-03-22 12y DC United 0 at Toronto FC 1 Jermain Colin Defoe CAN-TORH 90min 1g
- 2013-09-28 13y DC United 1 at Toronto FC 4 Darel Russell CAN-TORH 90min 1g
- 2013-08-24 13y Toronto FC 1 at DC United 1
- 2013-06-15 13y Toronto FC 2 at DC United 1 Robert Earnshaw CAN-TORH 80min 1g
- 2012-10-06 14y DC United 1 at Toronto FC 0 Hamdi Salihi USA-DCJH 26min 1g
- 2012-05-19 14y Toronto FC 1 at DC United 3 Dwayne De Rosario USA-DCJH 90min 2g yc
- 2012-05-05 14y DC United 2 at Toronto FC 0 Brandon Marquee McDonald USA-DCJH 90min 2a
- 2011-08-06 15y Toronto FC 3 at DC United 3
- 2011-04-16 15y DC United 3 at Toronto FC 0 Chris Pontius USA-DCJH 90min 2g yc
- 2010-10-23 15y Toronto FC 3 at DC United 2 Dwayne De Rosario USA-PHTF 90min 2g
- 2010-09-11 16y DC United 1 at Toronto FC 0 Julius James USA-DCJH 90min 1g
- 2009-08-15 17y DC United 0 at Toronto FC 2 Dwayne De Rosario CAN-TORH 90min 1g
- 2009-05-09 17y Toronto FC 3 at DC United 3
- 2008-05-24 18y Toronto FC 2 at DC United 3 Gonzalo Peralta USA-DCJH 90min 1g
- 2008-05-21 18y DC United 0 at Toronto FC 1 Daniele Salvatore Dichio CAN-TORH 90min 1g
- 2008-04-05 18y Toronto FC 1 at DC United 4 Santino Quaranta USA-DCJH 90min 1g
- 2007-09-29 19y Toronto FC 1 at DC United 4 Helbert Frederico Carreiro Da Silva USA-DCJH 90min 1g
- 2007-08-25 19y DC United 1 at Toronto FC 0 Helbert Frederico Carreiro Da Silva USA-DCJH 90min 1g
- 2007-05-19 19y DC United 2 at Toronto FC 1 Jaime Moreno Morales USA-DCJH 87min 1g