- 2024-09-28 2y Illinois Fighting Illini 7 at Penn State Nittany Lions 21 Drew Allar PSU 15/21-135yd 4run-15yd
- 2023-09-16 3y Penn State Nittany Lions 30 at Illinois Fighting Illini 13 Drew Allar PSU 16/33-208yd 6run-24yd
- 2021-10-23 4y Illinois Fighting Illini 20 at Penn State Nittany Lions 18 Artur Sitkowski ILL 8/19-38yd
- 2020-12-19 5y Illinois Fighting Illini 21 at Penn State Nittany Lions 56 Sean Clifford PSU 16/22-285yd 9run-yd 2td
- 2018-09-21 8y Penn State Nittany Lions 63 at Illinois Fighting Illini 24 Trace McSorley PSU 12/19-160yd 15run-92yd 3td
- 2015-10-31 10y Illinois Fighting Illini 0 at Penn State Nittany Lions 39 Christian Hackenberg PSU 21/29-266yd 1rec-14yd 2td 1td
- 2014-11-22 11y Penn State Nittany Lions 14 at Illinois Fighting Illini 16 Reilly O'Toole ILL 18/25-157yd 4run-8yd 1td
- 2013-11-02 12y Illinois Fighting Illini 17 at Penn State Nittany Lions 24 Christian Hackenberg PSU 20/32-240yd 5run-10yd 1td 1td
- 2012-09-29 14y Penn State Nittany Lions 35 at Illinois Fighting Illini 7 Matt McGloin PSU 18/30-211yd 1td 2td
- 2011-10-29 14y Illinois Fighting Illini 7 at Penn State Nittany Lions 10 Matt McGloin PSU 9/24-98yd
- 2010-10-09 16y Illinois Fighting Illini 33 at Penn State Nittany Lions 13
- 2009-10-03 17y Penn State Nittany Lions 35 at Illinois Fighting Illini 17
- 2008-09-27 18y Illinois Fighting Illini 24 at Penn State Nittany Lions 38
- 2007-09-29 19y Penn State Nittany Lions 20 at Illinois Fighting Illini 27
- 2006-10-21 20y Illinois Fighting Illini 12 at Penn State Nittany Lions 26
- 2005-10-22 21y Penn State Nittany Lions 63 at Illinois Fighting Illini 10
- 2002-11-02 23y Illinois Fighting Illini 7 at Penn State Nittany Lions 18
- 2001-11-10 24y Penn State Nittany Lions 28 at Illinois Fighting Illini 33
- 2000-10-21 26y Illinois Fighting Illini 25 at Penn State Nittany Lions 39
- 1999-10-30 26y Penn State Nittany Lions 27 at Illinois Fighting Illini 7
- 1998-10-31 27y Illinois Fighting Illini 0 at Penn State Nittany Lions 27
- 1997-10-04 29y Penn State Nittany Lions 41 at Illinois Fighting Illini 6
- 1994-11-12 31y Penn State Nittany Lions 35 at Illinois Fighting Illini 31
- 1993-11-13 32y Illinois Fighting Illini 14 at Penn State Nittany Lions 28
- 1972-10-07 54y Penn State Nittany Lions 35 at Illinois Fighting Illini 17
- 1960-10-22 65y Penn State Nittany Lions 8 at Illinois Fighting Illini 10
- 1959-10-24 66y Penn State Nittany Lions 20 at Illinois Fighting Illini 9
- 1954-09-25 72y Penn State Nittany Lions 14 at Illinois Fighting Illini 12