- 2026-09-19 3w BYU Cougars 41 at Colorado State Rams 23 Bear Bachmeier BYU 12/16-227yd
- 2010-11-13 15y BYU Cougars 49 at Colorado State Rams 10
- 2009-09-26 17y Colorado State Rams 23 at BYU Cougars 42
- 2008-11-01 17y BYU Cougars 45 at Colorado State Rams 42
- 2007-11-03 18y Colorado State Rams 16 at BYU Cougars 35
- 2006-11-04 19y BYU Cougars 24 at Colorado State Rams 3
- 2005-10-15 21y Colorado State Rams 14 at BYU Cougars 24
- 2004-10-02 22y BYU Cougars 31 at Colorado State Rams 21
- 2003-10-09 23y Colorado State Rams 58 at BYU Cougars 13
- 2002-10-24 23y BYU Cougars 10 at Colorado State Rams 37
- 2001-11-01 24y Colorado State Rams 34 at BYU Cougars 56
- 2000-11-02 25y BYU Cougars 21 at Colorado State Rams 45
- 1999-09-16 27y Colorado State Rams 13 at BYU Cougars 34
- 1995-09-30 31y BYU Cougars 28 at Colorado State Rams 21
- 1994-09-17 32y Colorado State Rams 28 at BYU Cougars 21
- 1993-09-18 33y BYU Cougars 27 at Colorado State Rams 22
- 1991-10-31 34y BYU Cougars 40 at Colorado State Rams 17
- 1990-10-13 36y Colorado State Rams 9 at BYU Cougars 52
- 1989-10-14 37y BYU Cougars 45 at Colorado State Rams 16
- 1988-10-08 38y Colorado State Rams 7 at BYU Cougars 42
- 1987-12-04 38y BYU Cougars 30 at Colorado State Rams 26
- 1986-10-03 40y Colorado State Rams 24 at BYU Cougars 20
- 1985-10-05 41y BYU Cougars 42 at Colorado State Rams 7
- 1984-10-06 42y BYU Cougars 52 at Colorado State Rams 9
- 1983-11-12 42y Colorado State Rams 6 at BYU Cougars 24
- 1982-10-23 43y Colorado State Rams 18 at BYU Cougars 34
- 1981-11-07 44y BYU Cougars 63 at Colorado State Rams 14
- 1980-11-15 45y Colorado State Rams 14 at BYU Cougars 45
- 1979-11-03 46y BYU Cougars 30 at Colorado State Rams 7
- 1978-09-23 48y Colorado State Rams 6 at BYU Cougars 32
- 1977-10-15 49y BYU Cougars 63 at Colorado State Rams 17
- 1976-09-18 50y Colorado State Rams 18 at BYU Cougars 42
- 1975-09-20 51y BYU Cougars 17 at Colorado State Rams 21
- 1974-10-05 52y BYU Cougars 33 at Colorado State Rams 33
- 1973-09-15 53y Colorado State Rams 21 at BYU Cougars 13
- 1972-10-28 53y BYU Cougars 44 at Colorado State Rams 8
- 1971-09-18 55y Colorado State Rams 14 at BYU Cougars 54
- 1970-11-07 55y BYU Cougars 9 at Colorado State Rams 26
- 1969-09-20 57y Colorado State Rams 20 at BYU Cougars 22
- 1966-09-30 60y Colorado State Rams 24 at BYU Cougars 27
- 1965-11-13 60y Colorado State Rams 36 at BYU Cougars 22
- 1964-10-10 62y BYU Cougars 6 at Colorado State Rams 7
- 1963-11-23 62y Colorado State Rams 20 at BYU Cougars 24
- 1962-10-06 64y BYU Cougars 28 at Colorado State Rams 7
- 1961-11-11 64y Colorado State Rams 16 at BYU Cougars 30
- 1960-10-01 66y BYU Cougars 7 at Colorado State Rams 8
- 1959-11-21 66y Colorado State Rams 13 at BYU Cougars 14
- 1958-10-04 68y BYU Cougars 6 at Colorado State Rams 32
- 1957-11-23 68y Colorado State Rams 9 at BYU Cougars 26
- 1956-09-29 70y BYU Cougars 0 at Colorado State Rams 0