- 2026-08-28 1mo Colgate Raiders 24 at Fordham Rams 14 Jake Stearney COLG 19/29-159yd 7run-24yd 1td
- 2025-09-20 1y Fordham Rams 21 at Colgate Raiders 44 Zach Osborne COLG 13/17-219yd 8run-45yd 2td 1td
- 2024-11-02 1y Colgate Raiders 14 at Fordham Rams 20 Jack Capaldi FORD 12/17-117yd 7run-24yd 1td 1td
- 2023-11-18 2y Fordham Rams 14 at Colgate Raiders 21 Jake Stearney COLG 11/22-123yd
- 2022-11-19 3y Colgate Raiders 38 at Fordham Rams 52 Tim DeMorat FORD 33/51-454yd 3run-8yd 6td
- 2021-11-20 4y Fordham Rams 31 at Colgate Raiders 45 Michael Brescia COLG 16/31-193yd 28run-yd 1rec-yd 2td 2td
- 2019-11-09 6y Fordham Rams 13 at Colgate Raiders 24 Grant Breneman COLG 15/28-195yd 16run-yd 1td
- 2018-11-03 7y Colgate Raiders 41 at Fordham Rams 0 Grant Breneman COLG 16/19-198yd 14run-17yd 1td
- 2017-10-14 9y Fordham Rams 12 at Colgate Raiders 38 Grant Breneman COLG 14/25-159yd 9run-22yd 3td
- 2016-11-05 9y Colgate Raiders 20 at Fordham Rams 24 Kevin Anderson FORD 27/42-263yd 3td
- 2015-10-31 10y Fordham Rams 29 at Colgate Raiders 31 Jake Melville COLG 17/26-241yd 16run-112yd 1td 2td
- 2013-11-23 12y Fordham Rams 56 at Colgate Raiders 19 Mike Nebrich FORD 29/38-395yd 5td
- 2012-11-17 13y Colgate Raiders 41 at Fordham Rams 39 Gavin McCarney COLG 12/20-212yd 22run-178yd 1td 1td
- 2011-10-01 15y Fordham Rams 14 at Colgate Raiders 38 Gavin McCarney COLG 11/17-157yd 12run-71yd 2td 2td