- 2026-08-29 1mo Robert Morris Colonials 28 at Wagner Seahawks 7 Carson Haggard RMU 32/19-206yd 2run-12yd 3td
- 2025-11-08 11mo Wagner Seahawks 24 at Robert Morris Colonials 20 Jack Stevens WAG 5/9-36yd 15run-92yd 1td
- 2024-09-21 2y Robert Morris Colonials 21 at Wagner Seahawks 14 Anthony Chiccitt RMU 17/27-219yd 7run-18yd 1td
- 2019-10-19 6y Robert Morris Colonials 21 at Wagner Seahawks 13 Caleb Lewis RMU 8/14-88yd 1td
- 2017-11-04 8y Robert Morris Colonials 7 at Wagner Seahawks 27 Luke Massei WAG 6/12-107yd 2td
- 2016-11-12 9y Wagner Seahawks 40 at Robert Morris Colonials 5 Alex Thomson WAG 18/31-258yd 4run-13yd 2td
- 2014-11-08 11y Wagner Seahawks 20 at Robert Morris Colonials 0 Chris Andrews WAG 8/18-95yd 10run-61yd 1td
- 2013-10-26 12y Robert Morris Colonials 17 at Wagner Seahawks 13 Marcus Prather RMU 17/33-204yd 2td
- 2012-10-27 13y Robert Morris Colonials 13 at Wagner Seahawks 23 Nick Doscher WAG 12/17-228yd 12run-3yd 1td
- 2011-11-12 14y Wagner Seahawks 38 at Robert Morris Colonials 17 Nick Doscher WAG 5/13-57yd 9run-46yd