- 2011-12-01 14y West Virginia Mountaineers 30 at South Florida Bulls 27 Geno Smith WV 23/35-237yd 5run-20yd
- 2010-10-14 16y South Florida Bulls 6 at West Virginia Mountaineers 20
- 2009-10-30 16y West Virginia Mountaineers 19 at South Florida Bulls 30
- 2008-12-06 17y South Florida Bulls 7 at West Virginia Mountaineers 13
- 2007-09-28 19y West Virginia Mountaineers 13 at South Florida Bulls 21
- 2006-11-25 19y South Florida Bulls 24 at West Virginia Mountaineers 19
- 2005-12-03 20y West Virginia Mountaineers 28 at South Florida Bulls 13