- 2025-11-15 11mo Eastern Michigan Eagles 24 at Ball State Cardinals 9 Noah Kim EMU 18/29-229yd 7run-21yd 1td 1td
- 2023-10-07 3y Ball State Cardinals 10 at Eastern Michigan Eagles 24 Austin Smith EMU 18/28-192yd 2td
- 2022-10-22 3y Eastern Michigan Eagles 20 at Ball State Cardinals 16 Austin Smith EMU 20/34-197yd 19run-52yd 1td
- 2021-10-16 4y Ball State Cardinals 38 at Eastern Michigan Eagles 31 Drew Plitt BSU 27/35-207yd 1td
- 2020-11-11 5y Eastern Michigan Eagles 31 at Ball State Cardinals 38 Drew Plitt BSU 22/31-232yd 1td
- 2019-10-12 7y Ball State Cardinals 29 at Eastern Michigan Eagles 23 Drew Plitt BSU 23/32-255yd 9run-6yd 1punt-38yd 2td 2td
- 2018-10-20 7y Eastern Michigan Eagles 42 at Ball State Cardinals 20 Tyler Wiegers EMU 22/28-257yd 6run-6yd 3td 1td
- 2017-11-02 8y Ball State Cardinals 14 at Eastern Michigan Eagles 56 Brogan Roback EMU 15/21-263yd 2run-10yd 3td
- 2016-11-08 9y Eastern Michigan Eagles 48 at Ball State Cardinals 41 Brogan Roback EMU 37/71-468yd 8run-41yd 3td 1td
- 2015-09-19 11y Ball State Cardinals 28 at Eastern Michigan Eagles 17 Riley Neal BSU 24/28-194yd 11run-86yd 1td 1td
- 2014-11-22 11y Eastern Michigan Eagles 30 at Ball State Cardinals 45 Jack Milas BSU 11/17-169yd 2run-57yd 2td 1td
- 2013-09-21 13y Ball State Cardinals 51 at Eastern Michigan Eagles 20 Keith Wenning BSU 17/28-317yd 2run-7yd 2td
- 2012-08-30 14y Eastern Michigan Eagles 26 at Ball State Cardinals 37 Keith Wenning BSU 26/41-267yd 6run-20yd
- 2011-11-05 14y Ball State Cardinals 33 at Eastern Michigan Eagles 31 Keith Wenning BSU 20/35-284yd 1run-1yd 2td
- 2010-10-16 16y Eastern Michigan Eagles 41 at Ball State Cardinals 38
- 2009-10-24 16y Ball State Cardinals 29 at Eastern Michigan Eagles 27
- 2008-10-25 17y Eastern Michigan Eagles 16 at Ball State Cardinals 38
- 2007-09-08 19y Ball State Cardinals 38 at Eastern Michigan Eagles 16
- 2006-08-31 20y Eastern Michigan Eagles 20 at Ball State Cardinals 38
- 2005-11-12 20y Ball State Cardinals 26 at Eastern Michigan Eagles 25
- 2004-10-09 22y Eastern Michigan Eagles 31 at Ball State Cardinals 24
- 2003-11-15 22y Ball State Cardinals 14 at Eastern Michigan Eagles 38
- 2002-10-19 23y Eastern Michigan Eagles 17 at Ball State Cardinals 42
- 2001-10-13 25y Ball State Cardinals 35 at Eastern Michigan Eagles 14
- 2000-10-14 26y Eastern Michigan Eagles 14 at Ball State Cardinals 33
- 1999-11-06 26y Ball State Cardinals 21 at Eastern Michigan Eagles 31
- 1998-09-12 28y Eastern Michigan Eagles 13 at Ball State Cardinals 7
- 1997-10-11 29y Ball State Cardinals 32 at Eastern Michigan Eagles 38
- 1996-11-02 29y Ball State Cardinals 39 at Eastern Michigan Eagles 25
- 1995-10-21 30y Eastern Michigan Eagles 40 at Ball State Cardinals 35
- 1994-10-29 31y Eastern Michigan Eagles 41 at Ball State Cardinals 20
- 1993-10-30 32y Ball State Cardinals 18 at Eastern Michigan Eagles 13
- 1992-10-10 34y Eastern Michigan Eagles 7 at Ball State Cardinals 31
- 1991-10-12 35y Ball State Cardinals 10 at Eastern Michigan Eagles 8
- 1990-11-10 35y Ball State Cardinals 20 at Eastern Michigan Eagles 13
- 1989-11-11 36y Eastern Michigan Eagles 17 at Ball State Cardinals 23
- 1988-10-15 38y Eastern Michigan Eagles 16 at Ball State Cardinals 12
- 1987-10-17 38y Ball State Cardinals 28 at Eastern Michigan Eagles 35
- 1986-11-01 39y Ball State Cardinals 7 at Eastern Michigan Eagles 14
- 1985-11-02 40y Eastern Michigan Eagles 27 at Ball State Cardinals 24
- 1984-10-27 41y Ball State Cardinals 17 at Eastern Michigan Eagles 10
- 1983-10-29 42y Eastern Michigan Eagles 20 at Ball State Cardinals 33
- 1982-10-30 43y Ball State Cardinals 16 at Eastern Michigan Eagles 7
- 1981-10-31 44y Eastern Michigan Eagles 13 at Ball State Cardinals 35
- 1980-10-18 45y Ball State Cardinals 26 at Eastern Michigan Eagles 0
- 1979-11-03 46y Eastern Michigan Eagles 10 at Ball State Cardinals 28
- 1978-10-28 47y Ball State Cardinals 21 at Eastern Michigan Eagles 0
- 1977-11-19 48y Eastern Michigan Eagles 21 at Ball State Cardinals 45
- 1976-11-20 49y Ball State Cardinals 52 at Eastern Michigan Eagles 3
- 1975-09-06 51y Eastern Michigan Eagles 14 at Ball State Cardinals 24