- 1993-09-04 33y Colgate Raiders 6 at Rutgers Scarlet Knights 68
- 1992-09-12 34y Colgate Raiders 0 at Rutgers Scarlet Knights 41
- 1990-09-15 36y Colgate Raiders 17 at Rutgers Scarlet Knights 28
- 1988-11-19 37y Colgate Raiders 22 at Rutgers Scarlet Knights 41
- 1985-11-16 40y Colgate Raiders 14 at Rutgers Scarlet Knights 28
- 1984-11-17 41y Colgate Raiders 7 at Rutgers Scarlet Knights 17
- 1983-10-15 43y Colgate Raiders 26 at Rutgers Scarlet Knights 29
- 1982-10-23 43y Colgate Raiders 17 at Rutgers Scarlet Knights 34
- 1981-09-12 45y Colgate Raiders 5 at Rutgers Scarlet Knights 13
- 1980-11-22 45y Colgate Raiders 13 at Rutgers Scarlet Knights 35
- 1978-11-25 47y Colgate Raiders 14 at Rutgers Scarlet Knights 9
- 1977-09-10 49y Rutgers Scarlet Knights 0 at Colgate Raiders 23
- 1976-11-25 49y Colgate Raiders 9 at Rutgers Scarlet Knights 17
- 1975-11-22 50y Colgate Raiders 14 at Rutgers Scarlet Knights 56
- 1974-11-23 51y Colgate Raiders 21 at Rutgers Scarlet Knights 62
- 1973-11-24 52y Colgate Raiders 42 at Rutgers Scarlet Knights 0
- 1972-11-25 53y Colgate Raiders 13 at Rutgers Scarlet Knights 43
- 1971-11-20 54y Colgate Raiders 16 at Rutgers Scarlet Knights 28
- 1970-11-21 55y Colgate Raiders 14 at Rutgers Scarlet Knights 30
- 1969-11-22 56y Colgate Raiders 12 at Rutgers Scarlet Knights 48
- 1968-11-23 57y Colgate Raiders 34 at Rutgers Scarlet Knights 55
- 1967-11-25 58y Colgate Raiders 28 at Rutgers Scarlet Knights 31
- 1966-11-19 59y Colgate Raiders 26 at Rutgers Scarlet Knights 7
- 1965-11-20 60y Colgate Raiders 24 at Rutgers Scarlet Knights 10
- 1964-11-21 61y Colgate Raiders 20 at Rutgers Scarlet Knights 7
- 1963-10-12 63y Rutgers Scarlet Knights 8 at Colgate Raiders 28
- 1962-10-13 64y Colgate Raiders 15 at Rutgers Scarlet Knights 27
- 1961-11-18 64y Rutgers Scarlet Knights 26 at Colgate Raiders 6
- 1960-10-08 66y Colgate Raiders 12 at Rutgers Scarlet Knights 49
- 1959-10-10 67y Colgate Raiders 12 at Rutgers Scarlet Knights 15
- 1958-10-04 68y Rutgers Scarlet Knights 21 at Colgate Raiders 7
- 1957-10-12 69y Rutgers Scarlet Knights 48 at Colgate Raiders 6
- 1956-10-13 70y Colgate Raiders 48 at Rutgers Scarlet Knights 6
- 1954-10-09 72y Rutgers Scarlet Knights 14 at Colgate Raiders 26
- 1953-10-31 72y Colgate Raiders 33 at Rutgers Scarlet Knights 13
- 1952-10-11 74y Rutgers Scarlet Knights 7 at Colgate Raiders 13
- 1951-11-24 74y Colgate Raiders 26 at Rutgers Scarlet Knights 21