- 2026-11-14 in 4w Lafayette Leopards at Colgate Raiders
- 2025-11-08 11mo Colgate Raiders 42 at Lafayette Leopards 59 Dean DeNobile LAF 18/29-206yd 1run-10yd 4td
- 2024-11-09 1y Lafayette Leopards 21 at Colgate Raiders 20 Dean DeNobile LAF 9/16-89yd
- 2023-11-04 2y Colgate Raiders 37 at Lafayette Leopards 34 Jake Stearney COLG 12/20-133yd 3run-24yd 2td
- 2022-11-05 3y Lafayette Leopards 21 at Colgate Raiders 16 Ah-Shaun Davis LAF 13/20-140yd 1punt-37yd 1td
- 2021-11-13 4y Colgate Raiders 20 at Lafayette Leopards 13 Michael Brescia COLG 9/15-144yd 24run-yd 2td
- 2019-11-16 6y Colgate Raiders 16 at Lafayette Leopards 0 Grant Breneman COLG 14/21-129yd 11run-yd 1td
- 2018-09-22 8y Lafayette Leopards 0 at Colgate Raiders 45 Grant Breneman COLG 12/17-115yd 17run-55yd 1td 1td
- 2017-11-11 8y Colgate Raiders 27 at Lafayette Leopards 0 Grant Breneman COLG 5/17-92yd 14run-25yd 1td
- 2016-11-12 9y Lafayette Leopards 17 at Colgate Raiders 38 Jake Melville COLG 15/23-202yd 17run-141yd 2td 1td
- 2015-11-07 10y Colgate Raiders 28 at Lafayette Leopards 19 Jake Melville COLG 9/18-145yd 12run-72yd 1td
- 2014-11-08 11y Lafayette Leopards 19 at Colgate Raiders 16 Blake Searfoss LAF 29/46-261yd 2td
- 2013-11-09 12y Colgate Raiders 28 at Lafayette Leopards 24 Gavin McCarney COLG 14/19-149yd 14run-88yd
- 2012-11-03 13y Lafayette Leopards 41 at Colgate Raiders 65 Gavin McCarney COLG 13/17-224yd 19run-288yd 2td 3td
- 2011-11-05 14y Colgate Raiders 24 at Lafayette Leopards 37 Andrew Shoop LAF 21/34-262yd 2td 1td
- 1981-10-17 44y Lafayette Leopards 0 at Colgate Raiders 30
- 1980-11-01 45y Lafayette Leopards 0 at Colgate Raiders 44
- 1979-11-03 46y Colgate Raiders 7 at Lafayette Leopards 7
- 1978-11-04 47y Lafayette Leopards 7 at Colgate Raiders 17
- 1977-09-17 49y Lafayette Leopards 12 at Colgate Raiders 38
- 1976-10-23 49y Colgate Raiders 24 at Lafayette Leopards 14
- 1975-10-25 50y Lafayette Leopards 2 at Colgate Raiders 56
- 1974-10-26 51y Colgate Raiders 24 at Lafayette Leopards 18
- 1973-09-22 53y Colgate Raiders 55 at Lafayette Leopards 21
- 1972-09-23 54y Lafayette Leopards 14 at Colgate Raiders 33
- 1971-11-13 54y Colgate Raiders 51 at Lafayette Leopards 14
- 1969-11-15 56y Colgate Raiders 14 at Lafayette Leopards 10
- 1968-11-16 57y Lafayette Leopards 14 at Colgate Raiders 10
- 1966-11-12 59y Colgate Raiders 20 at Lafayette Leopards 9
- 1965-09-18 61y Lafayette Leopards 0 at Colgate Raiders 40