- 1977-10-15 49y Lehigh Mountain Hawks 0 at Rutgers Scarlet Knights 20
- 1976-10-16 50y Rutgers Scarlet Knights 28 at Lehigh Mountain Hawks 21
- 1975-10-11 51y Rutgers Scarlet Knights 20 at Lehigh Mountain Hawks 34
- 1974-10-12 52y Lehigh Mountain Hawks 16 at Rutgers Scarlet Knights 37
- 1973-09-22 53y Rutgers Scarlet Knights 31 at Lehigh Mountain Hawks 13
- 1972-09-23 54y Lehigh Mountain Hawks 13 at Rutgers Scarlet Knights 41
- 1971-10-09 55y Lehigh Mountain Hawks 35 at Rutgers Scarlet Knights 14
- 1970-10-10 56y Rutgers Scarlet Knights 0 at Lehigh Mountain Hawks 7
- 1969-10-11 57y Lehigh Mountain Hawks 17 at Rutgers Scarlet Knights 7
- 1968-10-12 58y Rutgers Scarlet Knights 29 at Lehigh Mountain Hawks 26
- 1967-10-07 59y Lehigh Mountain Hawks 7 at Rutgers Scarlet Knights 14
- 1966-10-08 60y Rutgers Scarlet Knights 42 at Lehigh Mountain Hawks 14
- 1965-10-09 61y Lehigh Mountain Hawks 0 at Rutgers Scarlet Knights 6
- 1964-10-10 62y Rutgers Scarlet Knights 20 at Lehigh Mountain Hawks 7
- 1963-10-19 62y Lehigh Mountain Hawks 6 at Rutgers Scarlet Knights 30
- 1962-10-20 63y Rutgers Scarlet Knights 29 at Lehigh Mountain Hawks 13
- 1961-10-21 64y Lehigh Mountain Hawks 15 at Rutgers Scarlet Knights 32
- 1960-10-22 65y Rutgers Scarlet Knights 8 at Lehigh Mountain Hawks 0
- 1959-10-24 66y Lehigh Mountain Hawks 0 at Rutgers Scarlet Knights 23
- 1958-10-25 67y Rutgers Scarlet Knights 44 at Lehigh Mountain Hawks 13
- 1957-10-19 68y Lehigh Mountain Hawks 13 at Rutgers Scarlet Knights 7
- 1956-10-27 69y Rutgers Scarlet Knights 13 at Lehigh Mountain Hawks 27
- 1955-10-22 70y Lehigh Mountain Hawks 21 at Rutgers Scarlet Knights 14
- 1954-10-23 71y Rutgers Scarlet Knights 13 at Lehigh Mountain Hawks 33
- 1951-10-20 74y Lehigh Mountain Hawks 21 at Rutgers Scarlet Knights 6
- 1950-10-28 75y Rutgers Scarlet Knights 18 at Lehigh Mountain Hawks 21