- 2025-09-20 1y Illinois Fighting Illini 10 at Indiana Hoosiers 63 Fernando Mendoza IND 21/23-267yd 7run-4yd 5td
- 2023-11-11 2y Indiana Hoosiers 45 at Illinois Fighting Illini 48 John Paddock ILL 24/36-507yd 4td
- 2022-09-02 4y Illinois Fighting Illini 20 at Indiana Hoosiers 23 Connor Bazelak IND 28/52-330yd 1td
- 2017-11-11 8y Indiana Hoosiers 24 at Illinois Fighting Illini 14 Richard Lagow IND 32/48-289yd 2td
- 2013-11-09 12y Illinois Fighting Illini 35 at Indiana Hoosiers 52 Nate Sudfeld IND 20/27-267yd 3td
- 2012-10-27 13y Indiana Hoosiers 31 at Illinois Fighting Illini 17 Nate Sudfeld IND 10/15-107yd 5run-1yd 2td
- 2011-10-08 15y Illinois Fighting Illini 41 at Indiana Hoosiers 20 Nathan Scheelhaase ILL 12/22-210yd 18run-88yd 3td 1td
- 2010-10-23 15y Indiana Hoosiers 13 at Illinois Fighting Illini 43
- 2009-10-17 16y Illinois Fighting Illini 14 at Indiana Hoosiers 27
- 2008-10-18 17y Indiana Hoosiers 13 at Illinois Fighting Illini 55
- 2007-09-22 19y Illinois Fighting Illini 27 at Indiana Hoosiers 14
- 2006-10-07 20y Indiana Hoosiers 34 at Illinois Fighting Illini 32
- 2005-10-08 21y Illinois Fighting Illini 13 at Indiana Hoosiers 36
- 2004-11-06 21y Indiana Hoosiers 22 at Illinois Fighting Illini 26
- 2003-11-08 22y Illinois Fighting Illini 14 at Indiana Hoosiers 17
- 2002-10-26 23y Indiana Hoosiers 14 at Illinois Fighting Illini 45
- 2001-10-13 25y Illinois Fighting Illini 35 at Indiana Hoosiers 14
- 2000-11-04 25y Indiana Hoosiers 35 at Illinois Fighting Illini 42
- 1999-10-02 27y Illinois Fighting Illini 31 at Indiana Hoosiers 34
- 1998-11-07 27y Indiana Hoosiers 16 at Illinois Fighting Illini 31
- 1997-11-01 28y Illinois Fighting Illini 6 at Indiana Hoosiers 23
- 1996-10-05 30y Indiana Hoosiers 43 at Illinois Fighting Illini 46
- 1995-10-07 31y Illinois Fighting Illini 17 at Indiana Hoosiers 10
- 1990-11-17 35y Illinois Fighting Illini 24 at Indiana Hoosiers 10
- 1989-11-18 36y Indiana Hoosiers 28 at Illinois Fighting Illini 41
- 1988-11-05 37y Indiana Hoosiers 20 at Illinois Fighting Illini 21
- 1987-11-07 38y Illinois Fighting Illini 22 at Indiana Hoosiers 34
- 1986-11-15 39y Illinois Fighting Illini 21 at Indiana Hoosiers 16
- 1985-11-16 40y Indiana Hoosiers 24 at Illinois Fighting Illini 41
- 1984-11-10 41y Illinois Fighting Illini 34 at Indiana Hoosiers 7
- 1983-11-12 42y Indiana Hoosiers 21 at Illinois Fighting Illini 49
- 1982-11-13 43y Illinois Fighting Illini 48 at Indiana Hoosiers 7
- 1981-11-14 44y Indiana Hoosiers 14 at Illinois Fighting Illini 35
- 1980-11-15 45y Illinois Fighting Illini 24 at Indiana Hoosiers 26
- 1979-11-10 46y Indiana Hoosiers 45 at Illinois Fighting Illini 14
- 1978-10-28 47y Illinois Fighting Illini 10 at Indiana Hoosiers 31
- 1977-10-22 48y Indiana Hoosiers 7 at Illinois Fighting Illini 21
- 1974-09-14 52y Indiana Hoosiers 0 at Illinois Fighting Illini 16
- 1973-09-15 53y Illinois Fighting Illini 28 at Indiana Hoosiers 14
- 1972-11-11 53y Indiana Hoosiers 20 at Illinois Fighting Illini 37
- 1971-11-06 54y Illinois Fighting Illini 22 at Indiana Hoosiers 21
- 1970-10-17 56y Indiana Hoosiers 30 at Illinois Fighting Illini 24
- 1969-10-18 56y Illinois Fighting Illini 20 at Indiana Hoosiers 41
- 1968-10-05 58y Illinois Fighting Illini 14 at Indiana Hoosiers 28
- 1967-10-07 59y Indiana Hoosiers 20 at Illinois Fighting Illini 7
- 1966-10-15 60y Illinois Fighting Illini 24 at Indiana Hoosiers 10
- 1965-10-16 61y Indiana Hoosiers 13 at Illinois Fighting Illini 34
- 1960-09-24 66y Indiana Hoosiers 6 at Illinois Fighting Illini 17
- 1959-09-26 67y Illinois Fighting Illini 0 at Indiana Hoosiers 20
- 1951-10-27 74y Illinois Fighting Illini 21 at Indiana Hoosiers 0